What Are the Pros and Cons of an Acrylic Shower Base Vs Tiles?

If you are in the process of planning to remodel or build a new bathroom, one of your main decisions is how you will finish the shower base. Tiles may seem like the traditional choice, but an acrylic shower base has become increasingly popular. Both options have benefits and drawbacks that are important to consider when making this decision. This article discusses these pros and cons to help decide which route is right for your home remodeling project.

Acrylic Shower Base

Acrylic shower bases provide a luxurious and cost-effective solution for modern bathrooms. Available in numerous colors and styles, these attractive shower bases offer an easy to clean and easy to install option for showers.

acrylic walls in the tub

The acrylic shower base is very easy to clean and it is durable!

Not only are they high quality and durable, but their lighter weight than other options make them ideal for installation in all types of settings. Acrylic shower bases add a beautiful and functional touch to your bathroom while offering a reliable, long lasting product that ensures water is safely contained where you need it most.


Installing an acrylic shower base is a great way to ensure your bathroom stays in excellent condition for years to come. Not only is an acrylic base durable and long-lasting, but it is also very easy to clean and maintain since it contains no grout or joints which can be difficult to keep mold-free. The nonporous surface of the acrylic can be quickly wiped down with a damp cloth so you do not have to worry about scrubbing the dirt and soap buildup that tends to accumulate in tile showers. It is also much less prone to chipping than some other materials, so you will not need to replace it anytime soon. Another great benefit is its relatively low cost compared to natural stone and other expensive options, yet still adds a sophisticated look inside your bathroom.


While an acrylic shower base has some advantages, such as being light in weight and relatively easy to install, it does have a few disadvantages. Most concerning is the issue of longevity – acrylic can chip or crack over time, potentially leading to water damage in the bathroom. Depending on the quality of the acrylic material, discoloration may also appear overtime and be difficult to remove. Acrylic materials are not considered as durable as other choices such as stone or natural rocks like granite or marble. Additionally, you may need to perform routine sealing and cleaning of the surface to ensure it does not become stained over time. All these considerations should be kept in mind when deciding if an acrylic shower base is right for your bathroom remodel.

Tile Shower Base

For a luxurious bathroom renovator, there is no better choice than a tile shower base. This classic look is not just beautiful to behold; it is also highly durable and easy to maintain. When properly installed, a tile shower base can last for many years with minimal upkeep. Not only that, but its unique texture provides an added layer of comfort as you enjoy your new shower experience. Whether you prefer bright colors or more muted tones, a tile shower base has a timeless beauty that will be sure to fit with any contemporary decor style.


Installing a tile shower base can have several advantages in any bathroom renovation. It usually has low maintenance requirements, meaning it will not scratch or chip. Durability is another benefit; a tiled surface is resistant to extreme temperatures, moisture, mold and mildew. Aesthetically speaking, tiles provide a lot of flexibility when it comes to design: homeowners can add pops of color if desired, create intricate patterns with multiple colors and shapes, or keep it minimal with just one neutral hue. Furthermore, tile provides more heat retention than plastic bases and other materials due to its unique properties that help regulate temperature—a nice bonus on cold mornings.


Installing a tile shower base can be a difficult process, and the resulting product may not be worth the effort. The reality is that tile is porous and requires regular maintenance to keep it in pristine condition; otherwise, unsightly staining or discoloration can occur quite quickly. Additionally, tiles themselves are quite brittle and prone to cracking or breaking with use or if cleaning products are used. Lastly, a tile shower base tends to cost more than other materials such as acrylic, making it more expensive overall. While there are some beautiful tile options available on the market, homeowners should consider other shower material options before settling on one made of tile.

In the end, you will have to decide what is best for your needs. If you are looking for an inexpensive option that can be installed quickly, then an acrylic shower base may be the right choice for you. However, if you want a more personalized look or need to make repairs to your existing tile shower, then tiles may be the better option. Weigh the pros and cons of each material before making your final decision.